ISSUES FOR THE PROFESSION OF
GOVERNMENT INFORMATION LIBRARIANS
March 15, 1999
Prepared by:
Patricia Cruse, Chair, Education Committee,
Government Documents Round Table (GODORT),
with special assistance from: Ann Roselle,
Sherry DeDecker,
and other members of the GODORT Education
Committee.
Introduction
With the continuing development of new
information technologies and other changes for libraries, there are many
new-sprung challenges as we reach the year 2000. Arguably government information,
whether federal, international, state, or local, has been impacted much
more heavily than other areas in the library. This is true for several
reasons:
-
-
technological innovations that facilitate
effective distribution,
-
the lack of copyright restrictions on many
government publications,
-
budget constraints that have forced government
bodies to find more cost effective means to distribute materials, and
-
pending legislative action mandating the electronic
distribution of government publications.
Until recently, government information has
operated in a relatively stable environment with libraries acquiring tangible
materials, housing the materials in their collections, and providing access
to a predictable group of users. Specifically, the Government Printing
Office (GPO), and the Federal Depository Library Program (FDLP) have operated
for over 100 years in partnership with public, academic, state, and special
libraries around the country providing access to the census materials,
congressional publications, reports from agencies, and myriad other materials.
However, in the last several years, there has been a dramatic change in
the way that FDLP does business due to the increased reliance on electronic
information. As of February 1999 FDLP Electronic Collection consisted of:
-
-
92,064 electronic titles available on GPO
Access,
-
-
45,858 electronic titles linked from GPO Access,
-
-
10,749 electronic titles distributed to FDL's
in tangible form (CD-ROMS, diskettes), and
-
approximately 15 million titles downloaded
from GPO Access every month. 1
This dramatic shift from paper to electronic
environment is not only occurring with U.S. documents, but also with international,
state, and local. Consequently, government information librarians are uniquely
positioned to provide a valuable perspective on future impacts across the
library profession.
The basic goals are the same, but new
challenges have been added
Despite the focus on change and new technology,
we should all realize that the basic goals of government information librarians
and other librarians remain the same: to provide access for patrons to
the information that they need. In the future, libraries will continue
to acquire, preserve, and provide access to materials as well as provide
reference service for patrons, answering their questions and directing
them to information resources. The real challenge is how we achieve these
goals as more resources move to electronic format, and furthermore how
we can exploit new technologies to help us realize these goals. Below we
discuss some of the key issues and considerations that we face as we move
forward into the new century.
-
Changes in training of government information
librarians
- Because of the shift from a paper to
an electronic environment, there is a growing need for better technological
training for government information librarians. Gone are the days that
providing access simply meant creating bibliographic records and shelving
materials. Today access means that many of us must have a detailed understanding
of both hardware and software, including computer networks, HTML code,
perl scripts, and other programming languages. In a recent survey of 187
academic government information librarians, 72% responded that they participate
in one way or another in the development of a World Wide Web (WWW) site.
2 This survey also
found that 45.7% of the respondents are "totally responsible" for providing
links to government information for the library's web site.
- Besides providing access to government
resources on the WWW, government information librarians also need to provide
access to data contained on CD-ROMs. Most government information libraries
have substantial collections of CD-ROMs issued by various government agencies.
For many users, CD-ROMs are the preferred method of access simply because
CD-ROMs allow for more user flexibility -- this is particularly true for
users who are working with numeric data. Consequently, government information
librarians must have the technical knowledge to support the CD-ROM workstations
whether standalone or networked. The problem of providing access to the
sheer number of CD-ROMs is compounded by the fact that there is no standard
software or operating system and government information librarians must
learn to successfully use many different search interfaces and extraction
programs to assist users.
- In addition to providing access to government
information via WWW pages, there is an ongoing need to integrate Internet
resources into our online catalogs. Government information librarians and
the GPO have been at the forefront of this effort. This has required government
information librarians to become more familiar with not only cataloging
standards, but also with online catalog systems and other knowledge access
management systems. Educational opportunities in these areas must be made
available to government information librarians to assist them as they continue
their efforts to provide the best possible access to the full range of
government information that is now available.
- Expansion of and changes in the user community
- As government information librarians,
we no longer serve a predictable user community such as a congressional
district, campus community, or local community. With the growth of the
Internet, the pool of potential patrons for a particular service has grown
dramatically. In a single day, we may answer questions at the reference
desk from graduate students, professors, elementary school students, and
others, as well as answer e-mail questions from around the world. In addition,
any number of unknown users will use web pages and other technologies that
we have created to access government information. With the increase in
the patron base, there is a corresponding increase in patrons' interests,
questions, and needs.
- Other factors have also increased the
number of patrons using government information. The organization of public
service points for government information has changed over the last several
years as documents and general reference desks have been merged at many
institutions. An Association of Research Libraries survey of 88 libraries
found that nearly 1/3 of the libraries had combined their reference services
in the past five years.3 In many cases
this has literally brought government documents out of the basement and
into the mainstream of public service. Significantly, 33% of library respondents
in this same survey found an increased demand for access to government
information.
- Changes in the nature of patron training/instruction
- As the patron population and their needs
change, user training and instruction becomes much more complex. According
to Jim Gillispie, Head of Government Publications, Johns Hopkins University,
"Teaching readers to find, use, and understand the collections libraries
make available is the most important aspect of our profession."4
Government information librarians can no longer rely on the typical "reference
interview" as the basis on which to evaluate the user's needs and to provide
the necessary instruction. Many inquiries are no longer made in person,
but by e-mail or telephone. In the case of WWW pages, we may never actually
communicate directly with the patron. Rather, we must rely upon detailed
help pages to guide the patrons through their information needs. Many of
us have had to navigate users through web pages over the phone and guide
them to the database that they want -- certainly, a different task than
guiding users through a printed copy of the Statistical Abstract of the
United States. Furthermore, along with instructing users about the content
of a government publication, we are also faced with teaching patrons how
to use the technology to access the materials. This can range from helping
a user download a current version of Acrobat to helping unzip a data file
and loading the data into a spreadsheet program.
- Increase in the scope of colleagues
- Technologies such as listservs, email,
and web pages have had an enormous impact on who and how government information
librarians communicate. In the survey of academic government information
librarians over 70% of the respondents felt that they were developing closer
ties with other government information librarians because of the Internet.
5 In designing WWW pages, we frequently consult
other government information librarians for assistance. More significantly,
nearly 30% of respondents indicated that they are developing closer ties
with individuals not directly associated with government information. Those
of us that specialize in government data and census information have learned
the language of GIS and spatial statistics, by interacting with geographers,
statisticians, and other specialists. The development of new relationships
also is occurring within the institution itself - "A total 47.8% of respondents
felt that they were developing closer ties with their systems/automation
unit." In sum, technology has expanded not only how we communicate, but
also with whom we communicate. This has forced government information librarians
to seek out experts in the field and apply new skills in the delivery of
government information.
- Change in the nature of the collection
- As detailed in other parts of this document,
many government information libraries are witnessing a decline in the acquisition
of tangible (paper, microfiche, etc.) federal, state, local, and international
publications. This is in marked contrast with the growing volume of government
publications available online as detailed in other parts of this document.
Government information libraries have had had to shift energies from the
daily tasks associated with processing a physical collection to providing
access to Internet resources. According to Jack Sulzer, Associate Dean
for Campus College Libraries, University Libraries, The Pennsylvania State
University, "librarians now should be planning to convert their 'processing'
time and resources to services." 6 This issue
has broader implications for government information librarians. Until quite
recently government information librarians' expertise and knowledge was
primarily based on their institution's tangible collections. For example,
librarians with direct access to old government publications were often
experts in historical research. However, a "just in time" approach to collection
development requires new skills to provide access. Jim Gillispie states
that, "'Just in time' often requires a highly proactive approach to acquiring
information from the most expedient source and delivering it via the fastest
available." 7 It requires that a librarian
understand not only the content of the information, but also where it is
located on the web, how it is arranged structurally, and how to manipulate
it once found. All of these tasks require a new set of skills.
Conclusions
The question is, "how can government information
librarians best take advantage of the challenges in our profession?" First
and foremost, there is a need to reaffirm our values and recognize that
our goal of providing access to government information remains the same.
How we most effectively achieve that goal requires that we:
-
-
educate ourselves in the use of new technologies,
-
recognize our changing patron base,
-
develop new instruction programs to facilitate
patron success in an online environment,
-
take advantage of the skills and expertise
of colleagues, and
-
shift our energies from providing access to
the physical collection to an online collection.
In order for real change to take place, all
government information librarians must be able to take advantage of new
technologies. For this to be achieved continuing education opportunities
must be available to all.
Endnotes:
1. Evans, Thomas C. Data for FDLP
Electronic Collection. E-mail to Patricia Cruse. 4 March 1999.
2. Roselle, Ann. "Racing to Keep
Up With an Electronic FDLP: Its Effect on Professional Relationships of
Academic Government Documents Librarians". Paper to be presented at the
9th ACRL National Conference on April 9, 1999.
3. Clark, Cynthia D., and Judy Horn.
"Organization Of Document Collections And Services: A SPEC Kit." Washington
DC: Association of Research Libraries, 1998.
4. Gillispie, Jim. "Assuring User
Success in a Networked Environment for Government Information." Collection
Management 23 no.3 (1998):1-8.
5. Roselle, Ann. "Internet-Related
Work Activities and Academic Government Documents Librarians' Professional
Relationships." Government Information Quarterly 16, no.2 (1999):149-68.
6. Sulzer, Jack. "U.S. Depository
Librarians in Reality and Myth, a Framework for a Future Government Information
Program." Journal of Government Information 23, no.3 (1996):307-25.
7. Gillispie, Jim. "Assuring User
Success in a Networked Environment for Government Information." Collection
Management 23 no.3 (1998):1-8.
GODORT Education Committee Home Page